Wednesday, August 29, 2007

How A League of Democracies Could Work

Matt over at Foreign Policy Watch has an excellent post challenging the recently-popular concept of a League or Concert of Democracies. Such a league, which I've been writing about for sometime now (here, here, and here), has been championed by Republican presidential candidates John McCain and Rudolph Giuliani, the Princeton Project on National Security, and Ivo Daalder and Robert Kagan. So what doesn't Matt like about the idea?

...this concept is a fundamental misunderstanding of how the world really works and is based on three false premises: that democracies are somehow more inclined to act in the name of the common goodwill; that democracies will agree not only on what is broken, but what needs to be done to fix it, and; that alliances are forged from common values, and not shared interests.

1. Democracies are more inclined to act... There is no reason to suspect that the creation of the League of Democracies will prompt increased attention to a situation such as, say, Darfur....In the case of Darfur, the international community has - to put it crudely - simply been too busy elsewhere. The ongoing conflict there has been only of peripheral interest to the US - it scarcely has the time or human resources at its disposal to provide the type of attention a challenge like Darfur requires. A nation acts when it is in its interest to do so and, most importantly, is actually available to do so. If anything, the competing priorities on the US foreign policy agenda (I'm looking at you, Iraq) prevent Washington from taking the sort of action on the ground in Darfur that would be necessary to end the bloodshed.

2. Collectively, democracies will do what needs to be done... To solve the litany of problems plaguing the international community today requires that states involved in the effort not only agree on what the threat is, but define its nature and agree on the steps needed to resolve the problem. By what objective standards are democracies more capable of this than other states?

In the end, the world's leading democracies already enjoy perhaps some of the closest and most interlinked alliances in all of history, yet are split on numerous foreign policy decisions - from Iraq and Iran to missile defense and arms sales to China. How would codifying their relationships into a formal "League of Democracies" make their ability to face today's threats to international security or their ability to agree any differently?

3. Alliances are built on shared values... This is the largest conceptual flaw behind the push for creating a League of Democracies, mistaking alliances among states for a nod that the two are in agreement for how the world should look both within and among states. Alliances are forged when interests between one or more states converge and a cooperative relationship between two states becomes the most realistic means of achieving shared goals. This is why the US has a closer relationship with Saudi Arabia than it does with, say, Belgium. (Pervez Musharaff and a few other Central Asian autocrats have often made quite useful partners in recent years, one might add.)
All of Matt's critiques are excellent, and right on the money. But the sum of his arguments don't add up to the total of his conclusions. He's right on all of his points: Democracies aren't necessarily any more likely to act on issues of low national interest, democracies aren't necessarily any more capable of coming to consensus, and shared values aren't always the strongest or best metric of mutual alliance.

But, to take the critiques in turn, the whole point of the league is to create a mechanism that will be more effective at spurring these countries into action. When Daalder and Kagan speak of creating a "formal mechanism" they presumably are thinking of some kind of enforcement mechanism as exists in the WTO that would bind states to their institutional commitments. The impetus behind finding a institution to replace the UN is to find one that works: That punishes states that break the rules and that forces its members to act when those rules have been broken.

Matt wonders why democracies would be any more likely than a mixed body to agree on means. Perhaps. But to discard the notion of an alliance on those grounds would be throwing out the baby with the bathwater. First, NATO, the WTO, and other institutions made of up like-minded states have certainly been more able to design coherent plans of action than has been the UN. Matt points to the problems experienced by the US surrounding the invasion of Iraq, but that seems to work against his argument, as Iraq was conducted outside of the framework of an institution. Iraq was done by the whims of the US, ignoring the advice and warnings of America's allies. A league would create some formal mechanism for planning, akin to NATO's unified command structure. Now, before you mention Kosovo, yes, I'm aware Kosovo was a problem for NATO planners. But it was still better than the UN could have done.

Finally, Matt argues that interests rather than values are the basis for partnerships in international politics, asking why, if the opposite were true, would the US have a closer relationship with Saudi Arabia than it does Belgium. This is a very short-sighted understanding of interest. While it's true that interest plays a role, the American interest in Saudi Arabia is a tactical one; oil. The American interest in Belgium is a much more long-term one; shared values. So while America may need to placate Saudi Arabia in the short-term to get access to oil or to get cooperation in counter-terror efforts on Iraq, the US relationship with Belgium is much stronger and deeper and is ultimately more fundamental to US and global security.

Matt's critiques are trenchant and powerful, but ultimately, unconvincing. Properly constructed (and that is no easy task), a league of democracies could be a powerful and meaningful force in international politics. The WTO has fired the first shot across the bow...will there be more?

14 comments:

MDC said...

Seth: I'll get back to your hsarp and insightful comments tomorrow when I have more time to think through a healthy response that merits attention from a professor. In the meantime, thanks for the free advertising! You know I agree with you on most everything with the exception of the LOD idea :)

Matt Bondy said...

Good points, Seth. I posted a brief comment at FPW which follows a similar line of thinking.

Cheers,
M

Anonymous said...

There is an added benefit it would seem to a League of Democracies. When you have a club, other people want to join. We would actually have a true incentive for nation states to become democratic.

Anonymous said...

To cbehnke:

when we are once again "democratic" or better yet the "republic" we were intended to be then i am all for that "club"

do more research please

Anonymous said...

It is the gw gold which make me very happy these days, my brother says GuildWars Gold is his favorite games gold he likes, he usually buy some Guild Wars Gold to start his game and most of the time he will win the GuildWars money back and give me some cheap gw gold to play the game.
I always heard something from my neighbor that he sometimes goes to the internet bar to play the game which will use him some habbo credits,he usually can win a lot of habbo gold,then he let his friends all have some habbo coins,his friends thank him very much for introducing them the buy habbo gold,they usually cheap habbo credits together.

Anonymous said...

Once I played stoneage2, I did not know how to get strong, someone told me that you must have stoneage2 Gold. He gave me some stoneage 2 Gold, he said that I could buy stoneage2 money, but I did not have money, then I played it all my spare time. From then on, I got some buy stoneage2 Gold, if I did not continue to play it, I can sell stoneage 2 money to anyone who want.

Once I played flyff, I did not know how to get strong, someone told me that you must have flyff penya. He gave me some flyff money, he said that I could buy flyff penya, but I did not have money, then I played it all my spare time. From then on, I got some flyff gold, if I did not continue to play it, I can sell cheap penya to anyone who want.

Anonymous said...

As a new player , you may need some game guides or information to enhance yourself.
requiem gold is one of the hardest theme for every class at the beginning . You must have a good way to manage your requiem lant.If yor are a lucky guy ,you can earn so many requiem money by yourself . But if you are a not , I just find a nice way to get cheap requiem lant. If you need , you can buy requiem online gold at our website . Go to the related page and check the detailed information . Once you have any question , you can connect our customer service at any time .

Making knight gold is the old question : Honestly there is no fast way to make lots of knight noah . Sadly enough a lot of the people that all of a sudden come to with millions of knight online gold almost overnight probably duped . Although there are a lot of ways to make lots of knight online noah here I will tell you all of the ways that I know and what I do to buycheap knight gold.

Anonymous said...

Making requiem gold is the old question : Honestly there is no fast way to make lots of requiem lant . Sadly enough a lot of the people that all of a sudden come to with millions of requiem money almost overnight probably duped . Although there are a lot of ways to make lots of cheap requiem lant here I will tell you all of the ways that I know and what I do to buyrequiem online gold.

Anonymous said...

One very common item bought with cheap SOF gold at the store would be a pet. The Gameim.com is offering you with Scions Of Fate money and all kinds of cheap game gold. Scions Of Fate gold is sometimes need to pay for in this Scions of Fate game. For example in this game, we have to buy sof gold to exchange premium in order to protect our character. The only part of this game will require you to pay SOF gold but they are optional for you to choose in the premium store.

Anonymous said...

I like to play last chaos, because I like its name, also I like last chaos gold. My friend told me that she would buy lastchaos gold for me, and I was so happy. I do not like to go shopping, because it always spends a lot of money, but I never hesitate to buy last chaos gold. You can buy cheap lastchaos gold; it is so easy and convenient. I believe the future of lastchaos money is bright.

Anonymous said...

rf gold which in RF Online Game is very popular for many players. Play this online game the premise that we have more enough rf online gold first. They are able to combine creative tools and weapons with some rf money and the Light form of universal magic. Under such sustained attacks they fell from power, yet they have bided their rf cp and time. Due to make cheap rf gold the intense gravity on their home planet, the Bellato are the smallest people.
runescape gold of RS Online Game, we have made several changes to Fun Orb. If you wish to buy runescape to explore other spell books, you should subscribe as a Fun Orb member. Shattered Plans - a galaxy-spanning strategy epic that use rs gold to allow up to six players to battle for supremacy. We only plan to pay cheap rs gold when we feel you will appreciate the updates. And we certainly feel that these changes and some runescape money are worth telling you about.

Anonymous said...

I did not know how to get strong, someone told me that you must have last chaos gold. He gave me some lastchaos gold, he said that I could buy last chaos gold, but I did not have money, then I played it all my spare time. From then on, I got some lastchaos money, if I did not continue to play it, I can sell cheap lastchaos gold to anyone who want.
Once I played Aion, I did not know how to get strong, someone told me that you must have aion kina. He gave me some aion kina, he said that I could buy aion gold, but I did not have money, then I played it all my spare time. From then on, I got some buy aion kina, if I did not continue to play it, I can sell cheap aion kina to anyone who want.

Anonymous said...

Do you know 2moons dil? I like it. My brother often go to the internet bar to buy 2moons gold and play it. After school, He likes playing games using these 2moon dil with his friend. I think that it not only costs much money but also spend much time. One day, he give me many buy 2moons dil and play the game with me. I came to the bar following him and found cheap 2moons gold was so cheap. After that, I also go to play game with him.

Anonymous said...

Do you know Archlord gold? I like it. My brother often goes to the internet bar to buy Archlord money and play it. After school, He likes playing games using these archlord online Gold with his friend. I think that it not only costs much money but also spend much time. One day, he give me many cheap Archlord gold and play the game with me. I came to the bar following him and found buy Archlord gold was so cheap.